Tuesday June 27, 2017

Grace Collier & The Big Picture

Written by David Marler
Hits: 2676
Grace Collier & The Big Picture 
Grace Collier The Big Picture   SUNDAY, June 16 2013, ABC Radio National Outsiders program hosted by Jonathan Green went to air. It would turn into the biggest scandal since Howard Sattler interviewed Prime Minister Julia Gillard and inferred first bloke, Tim Mathieson was gay because he was a hairdresser.

Yes, that was only four days earlier.

On the panel to discuss that and the 'Pandora's box of political sexism', National Affairs Editor for Crikey, Bernard Keane; writer, feminist, sociologist and social commentator, Eva Cox and Grace Collier, columnist & industrial relations consultant.
For the first half of the interview it was a reasonable enough discussion on the events of the past few weeks.  The Prime Minister's 'blue tie' speech featured prominently. Also taking centre stage was 'Menugate' (where references to body parts of the PM were printed on a menu that was never distributed to tables at a Liberal party fundraiser).

As the discussion moved to the Prime Minister's gender agenda, Grace Collier questioned the statement that the PM was constantly being attacked for being a woman.

"The Prime Minister, in my view, has a dysfunctional relationship with the Australian populace and there is an element there of responsibility that falls on her shoulders..."

Eva Cox explained that there were two different issues, the PM not being good at the job and that being attacked for being a woman was inappropriate.

"Not doing well at the job because she's not doing well at the job but then attacking her for being a woman is inappropriate."

"Well, I’ve never heard anyone attacking her for being a woman," Ms Collier stated.

Ms Cox explained, "Read some of the commentaries, read some of the stuff there. I mean, which male Prime Minister has ever been asked if his wife that is actually having sex with him at that particular time or having sex with some other woman. I mean they would not do it to a man."

Ms Collier appeared to agree with Eva Cox but then made an unexpected right hand turn across three lanes of traffic.

"Well, also I agree with that but also, I don’t think it is appropriate for a Prime Minister to be showing her cleavage in parliament. It is not something…"

At which point both Bernard Keane and Eva Cox seemed lost for words.

Keane: Oh, for goodness sake … what a load of …

Cox: Come one Grace …

Collier: Well, I think it is inappropriate and unprofessional …

Keane: Grace, can you … explain

Collier: No, I … No Bernard, I’m not here to explain to you. I think it is just … I’m entitled to my opinion.

Keane: Just explain … just explain

Green: One at a time …

Collier: I’d like to finish my point.

Keane: … is somehow not related to the fact that she’s a woman. How can you …

Good lord, the Prime Minister's cleavage now!

The conversation descends into a discussion about right wing politics with Ms Collier taking exception to being labelled as part of the 'right'.

So what exactly was Grace Collier referring to here?

If we step back a month, Ms Collier tweeted a photo of the PM and condemned her attire in Parliament. (Click to enlarge for better view).

The photo appears distorted and some have suggested 'photo shopped' with the PM's head placed on another body.

I'll come to that one in a moment.

However, was it really a photo of the PM? Let's pan out and look at the original picture.
  Grace Collier The Big Picture Photo Tweet of PM 
The original photo is attributed to News Limited photographer, Gary Ramage circa 2007.  It shows Prime Minister Kevin Rudd seated in Parliament in front of Wayne Swan and Julia Gillard.
On 4th May, 2013 The Australian published an opinion piece by Henry Ergas entitled, 'Bad policy does not just happen' discussing Labor's fiscal strategy in 2007 and comparing it to present day. The photo was included as a reference to that time.

It is at this point that Ms Collier sends out her disapproving tweet.

Shortly after her ABC Radio National interview, Ms Collier was challenged over twitter that the photo had been altered. (Click the image below to view the conversation).

She explained that she had taken a picture of the photo from The Australian newspaper with her iPhone.  At the angle the iPhone was held, it does tend to distort the image.
  Picture: Gary Ramage Source: The Australian
that photo is from the Australian newspaper, taken with my iphone, you fool.   What have we proven?

The image tweeted by Ms Collier did not tell the entire story. Julia Gillard was not the Prime Minister at the time the photo was taken.

Remember, that during the ABC Radio National interview, Ms Collier's point about the Prime Minister was that she "has a dysfunctional relationship with the Australian populace."
She also challeneged the statement that the Prime Minister was attacked because she was a woman and then threw in the, "I don’t think it is appropriate for a Prime Minister to be showing her cleavage in parliament" line.

Ms Collier has obscured the facts. She has not told us the entire story behind the photo.

So what? I'm quite sure she can find another photo of the Prime Minister wearing something 'inappropriate' to share.

However, as readers and viewers, is this what we want to see from our journalists and politicians? To see constant attacks against the Prime Minister of Australia based on her body shape and what she wears?

Some will answer yes. While she does not like to be labelled as 'right wing', many of Ms Collier's tweets are anti-Gillard Government in nature. Her followers delight in her statements and picture shares. You can check out her timeline here, @MsGraceCollier.

Personally, as a reader and viewer, this exercise has made me question Grace Collier as a genuine political commentator.  She's also not shy of the odd media stunt as in the James Bond style microphone in her bra episode. (You can read that story below).

Can I gain insight and information on the current political situation from her? Would I spend time reading her columns or watching her segments on PMLive?

I think not.

Blue ties, quail breasts and hairdressers

Full Interview: ABC Radio National: 'Blue ties, quail breasts and hairdressers'

Julia Gillard’s cleavage and Grace Collier, the “human booby trap”

'Julia Gillard’s cleavage and Grace Collier, the “human booby trap”'

Julia Gillard’s cleavage and Grace Collier, the “human booby trap”

'Busted: union foils tape in bra spy bid'

Bad policy does not just happen

'Bad policy does not just happen'

Update 19 June, 2013 - Andrew Bolt Says Grace Collier Is 'Simply Wrong'.

Ms Grace Collier has confirmed that it was The Australian photo that was the point of reference in her ABC Radio National interview.

Journalist Andrew Bolt objected to the 'right-wing' labeling of Ms Collier but added, "In this case, however, I think Collier is simply wrong - on the evidence."
  Grace Collier The Big Picture: Oz Confirm
** Can I please stress that the twitter account displayed, "Bolts Blogs @AndrewBoltsBlog" is NOT affiliated with journalist Andrew Bolt **

Below is the link to the real Andrew Blog blog and his thoughts on Ms Grace Collier's interview.
Grace Collier becomes a “right-winger” for criticising Gillard’s cleavage

Andrew Bolt Blog: 'Grace Collier becomes a “right-winger” for criticising Gillard’s cleavage'

The Big Wet: Bundaberg Flood 2013

Norsefire Burning

Qld School Closures

Fennel - The Misunderstood Vegetable

The real truth of sexism and misogyny in Australia

Qld's Responsible Government?

Passionate About Respectful Politics

#BattleRort Reloaded

S5 Box